Categories
Adding Value, Home Buyer Tips in Utah, Home Improvements, Home Sellers, Home Seller Tips, Home Selling, Home Selling Mistakes, Real Estate Education, Selling and Buying in UtahPublished November 12, 2026
Function Beats Novelty: What Actually Sells a Home?
Function Beats Novelty: What Actually Sells a Home?
Recently, while touring homes with some clients, one of them made a comment that stuck with me. "Abe, you've got a really cool job." And they're right! As a real estate agent, I get to travel throughout the greater Salt Lake area, explore different neighborhoods, and walk through some truly remarkable homes. I've seen beautiful architecture, unusual floor plans, incredible custom features, and properties that are unlike anything else on the market. But after seeing thousands of homes, I've come to recognize an interesting pattern. "The most interesting homes aren't necessarily the ones buyers want to purchase".
Novelty Gets Attention, but Function Sells
There's something exciting about walking into a home with a spiral staircase, a massive balcony overlooking the mountains, or a completely unconventional design. Those features create memorable experiences. They get people talking. Sometimes they're even the highlight of a showing. But here's what I've learned: Being memorable doesn't necessarily make a home marketable.
Buyers might love the appearance of a spiral staircase, but how practical is it when carrying laundry or moving furniture? That oversized balcony might offer incredible views, but what happens when buyers realize there's no convenient access to the backyard? Suddenly, something that initially seemed exciting becomes a potential inconvenience. And that's where novelty starts working against the property.
Buyers Still Want the Fundamentals
Most buyers aren't looking for the most unusual house in the neighborhood. They're looking for a home that makes sense for their lives. They don't necessarily want something that's "cookie cutter," but they do want a functional floor plan, comfortable living spaces, adequate storage, a convenient location, and a price that aligns with the property's value. These characteristics aren't necessarily exciting, but they're consistently important. I've toured some incredibly unique properties that buyers admired but ultimately passed on. Not because the homes lacked character, but because their unusual designs required too many compromises.
A Little Character Goes a Long Way
Now, don't misunderstand me. I'm not suggesting every home should look identical or that homeowners should avoid creativity. I think one or two distinctive features can make a home stand out beautifully. A retro conversation pit, a unique fireplace, or a thoughtfully designed entertainment space can give a property personality. But there has to be a balance.
I've toured homes where one feature completely overshadows everything else. Imagine a moderately updated home with a state-of-the-art recording studio, or an extravagant backyard pool while the rest of the house feels relatively ordinary. That one feature becomes the heartbeat of the property rather than something that complements the home as a whole. When unusual features begin dominating the entire home, they can narrow the number of buyers who find the property appealing. The more eclectic a home becomes, the more specific its ideal buyer may need to be. And when you're selling real estate, appealing to a broader pool of qualified buyers is generally an advantage.
The Sweet Spot
Whether you're buying, selling, or considering renovations, remember that personal taste and market appeal aren't always the same thing. Enjoy the features that make your home special, but don't overlook the importance of practicality. After touring countless properties, I've become convinced of one simple principle: Novelty may attract attention, but function creates demand. The best homes don't necessarily make the biggest impression. They're the ones that make the most sense. At Lemonade Real Estate, we're passionate about helping our clients recognize that difference.
Sweetly Guiding You Home.
or another way
